The Fancy and the Fooled

is the ninety-seventh episode of the second campaign of Critical Role. Live from Chicago! The Mighty Nein return to Nicodranas, where happy reunions and fantastic makeovers are shadowed by revelations about someone close to the party...

Pre-Show
Brian Wayne Foster thanks everyone present in the Auditorium Theater in Chicago for patiently waiting outside in the cold, and for being the best community based on a D&D show from a home game based on a thing. He goes over the ground rules for the live audience and introduces the cast, dressed for TravelerCon, and Sam, dressed as a... leprechaun? Matt says this is what they get for defying an archfey's wishes to avoid the theater.

Announcements

 * Tonight's live Saint Paddy's day episode is brought to you by the color green, the luck of the Irish, and by World Anvil, world-building software that allows you to homebrew worlds for your adventures. Use the code "CRITROLE" at checkout for 20% off 6- and 12-month memberships. Deepest apologies to all Irish viewers.
 * The second sponsor tonight is the faithful D&D Beyond, the online tool for keeping track of your campaigns and characters.
 * The cast is at C2E2 this weekend. There will be a panel Saturday on the main stage. Merch is available through the C2E2 merch booth.

Previously on Critical Role
''So, last we left off, the Mighty Nein had made their way down to the Whitedawn Lagoon in search of the whereabouts of Caduceus Clay’s family, who had long one-by-one vanished over time, in search of this familial task that was put upon them by their patron deity, the Wildmother. Upon discovering the family and many others turned to stone by some sort of a Mistkath mutation of a gorgon, you managed to save most of the people who were necessary, and then through a clever use of magic and some really high medicine rolls, did save the one who got shattered in the middle of the battle, completed what seemed to be the final leg of this vision quest, and sent the now-safe family of Caduceus Clay back to their home at the Blooming Grove.''

''You guys then made your way to Nicodranas, to figure out how to prepare yourselves for the coming negotiation between the Kryn Dynasty and the Dwendalian Empire during the ceasefire, which you were told you don’t need to be there, but you insisted regardless. And as such, you’ve Teleported, without forewarning, into the Tidepeak Tower of Yussa in Nicodranas. And that’s where we left off last. So, as you guys all arrive into the darkened chamber, the inside of Yussa’s tower, what would you like to do?''

Part I
The party is greeted by Wensforth, who lets them out of Tidepeak, and they decide to visit their ship first to check in. Nott tells them that she had promised Yeza that the next time she saw him, she wouldn't still be a goblin, and after thinking a lot about it, she's ready to transform back into Veth now.

The harbor is unusually busy, with two notable ships present (other than their own): The Blue Heaven under Captain Dremmy holds the emissary from the Empire and is a large, ornate, and well-guarded Empire vessel, and the Wind of Aeons, flying the Cerberus Assembly flag. They go over to their own ship, the Ball-Eater, and are greeted by Marius LePual and acting captain Orly Skiffback, who tells them the ship is ready to depart when they are.

The party then goes to the Wind of Aeons where they find Martinet Ludinus Da'leth in conversation with Lord Athesius Uludan, Archmage of Diplomatic Union for the Assembly, and Lord Desran Thane, a lord of Nicodranas. While Thane appears nervous, Athesius invites them to a party the next evening at the home of the Marquis of Nicodranas and extends the invitation to the Ruby of the Sea, Jester's mother. Caleb covertly summons Frumpkin to the dock to watch and follow Thane if he leaves the ship, and asks that the party be allowed to look at the beacon sometime before departure for the talks. Ludinus agrees, and he and Lord Thane go together below decks.

At Beau's urging, Caleb sends Frumpkin to spy on the conversation between Da'leth and Thane. When Da'leth casts a dispel magic spell to thwart magical eavesdropping, Thane is revealed to actually be Essek Thelyss, who was startled by the sudden appearance of the Mighty Nein. Ludinus states that it is important that they oversee the control and exchange of the prisoners and the delivery of the beacon, but that afterward, they need never interact again, beyond the Assembly sharing its research as agreed. Essek agrees, resumes his disguise, and heads back up on deck. The party returns to their ship, where Caleb reveals what Frumpkin saw and heard. They realize Essek was probably the Dynasty official that handed the two beacons to the Empire in the first place, but decide they should give him a chance to explain himself.

On the way to the Lavish Chateau, they purchase the gem dust and clay they will need for the Transmogrification ritual. Nott casts Invisibility on herself so that neither her son nor her husband will see her in her goblin form. Marion greets them warmly, Luc seems to be thriving and mischievous, and Yeza is quick to enquire about his wife and be told she is on her way. Jester tells her mother that the others have now all met and seen the Traveler and that, while he's not a god, he's real. Marion recalls seeing such a man a few times downstairs in the past. Jester invites her to come to the party with them, and after some hesitation, Marion agrees.

The party takes over Marion's bathroom (and expensive bathtub) to perform the Transmogrification ritual. Nott says farewell and thanks individually to each of the Nein, finally telling Caleb that she loves him, and he replies, "I... love you too, Veth the Brave." With that, they begin the ritual, which takes an hour to complete. During it, Nott becomes completely encased within the clay, which begins glowing orange hot, finally shattering in an arcane shock wave to reveal the halfling form of Veth Brenatto. Yeza arrives, having heard the explosion, and Veth is reunited with her husband and son. After asking the party to watch Luc, Yeza and Veth retire to his bedchamber and close the door.

Break

 * D&D Beyond animation.
 * Ad for World Anvil, the ultimate worldbuilding platform and campaign manager.
 * Magic! Sam, Liam, and guest Ashly Burch explore the arcane in All Work No Play 3 March 2020 at 4:00 pm PST on Critical Role's Twitch channel.
 * Clips from.
 * Dani just wants to watch her Critical Role! Taliesin is here to help, with a subscription to Critical Role's Twitch channel.
 * Critters’ art montage.

Part II
Caleb asks Jester to lead him to a magic shop where he might buy a scroll and the paper and ink to transcribe it. Unfortunately there isn't a magic shop in Nicodranas, so Jester suggests asking Yussa Errenis, and they (along with Fjord) head to Tidepeak Tower. Yussa has the spell Globe of Invulnerability that Caleb is looking for, and allows him to copy it in exchange for signing over ownership of Willi, who has been staying with Yussa for repairs. Caduceus and Jester realize they're going to need outfits for the party the next night, and the rest of the group agrees to let them outfit them all. While they shop and Caleb is busy transcribing his spell, Fjord, Yasha, and Beau head to the fish market, where Fjord sits uncomfortably as the two women do some mild flirting.

The next day, their outfits arrive, pleasing everyone with the excellent choices made by Jester and Caduceus. That evening, Jester holds Marion's hand tightly as they walk to the Marquis Demesne, and they arrive safely at the small palace, where drinks and food are being passed by servants and soft music is playing. Marion leaves them to prepare for her performance. Jester spots Lord Robert Sharpe, the man whose threat to have her killed in retaliation for her humiliating prank on him drove her to leave her home in Nicodranas before she met the rest of the Mighty Nein, and hides behind Fjord, but Sharpe approaches the group and starts making unwelcome and smarmy advances on Yasha, who doesn't know how to handle them. Jester steps out and tells him to leave Yasha alone. She successfully casts Charm Person on him, and sends him out onto a balcony to retrieve her fictional glove, locking the door behind him which Veth then seals with the Dagger of Denial.

Caduceus casts True Seeing on Beau, giving her Truesight and allowing her to see into the Ethereal Plane, but also making her seem as if she's high. Fjord strikes up a conversation with Captain Dremmy of the Blue Heaven, learning that it will be carrying the important individuals for the negotiations. Caleb talks to Ludinus Da'leth, who tells him that Trent Ikithon has not accompanied him to the peace talks.

Veth has turned invisible and hides under a table to spy on Lord Thane (who they know to be a disguised Essek Thelyss) while Jester engages him in conversation. When Marion's performance starts, Veth slips a paralysis potion into Thane's drink. Not knowing what's happening, Jester pulls the paralyzed Thane out of the room, joined by the rest of the Nein except Fjord and Beau. When the potion wears off, Caleb immediately slaps the Manacles of Stasis on him, but Thane vanishes from them and reappears thirty feet away. Caduceus casts Command on him and tells him to Stop, and they convince him he really should talk to them, heading back to the Ball-Eater together.

Back at the party, Beau has spotted a black-scaled dragonborn disguised as a Dwendalian noble. She and Fjord confront him and he tells them he's secretly a former member of Draconian nobility who just wants to be left alone. Caleb casts Message to Beau and then Fjord, telling them the rest of the group is heading back to their ship, but Fjord misses the location and it's a while before Jester uses Sending to find out where they are and tell them to come to the ship.

Meanwhile, in a quiet cabin on the ship surrounded by the Nein, Essek drops his illusion and they ask what he's doing. He confesses that it was he who gave the two beacons to the Empire, in return for their promise to share their research and knowledge with him. When the party appeared in Rosohna with the first one, he got close to them in order to be able to keep them from getting too close to the truth. Unfortunately, he started liking them. He believes he is irredeemable and that he deserves the pain he now feels for putting them in danger for the sake of pursuing new knowledge that could change everything.

Caleb sees the close parallels between his own situation and Essek's, and urges him to seize this one opportunity to change and save himself, telling him that although they may both be damned, they "can choose to do something and leave it better than it was before." Essek tells them the Empire is returning the beacon that he gave them and keeping the new one they just found. They all want to end the war as it has run its purpose, and hope that with the return of both beacons, no one will ever know what they did. The only people aware of the truth are Essek, Da'leth, Ikithon, and Vess DeRogna - and now, of course, the Mighty Nein, who are safe as long as they keep quiet. As Veth says, "We're just supposed to turn the other way and pretend like you're not all a bunch of traitors."

Caleb warns Essek that there is a high likelihood that the Assembly means to kill him, and, agreeing, Essek sees the value in surrounding himself with friends to protect him. He has more allegiance to them than to either the Dynasty or the Empire. Veth tells him that he is a broken person who had ill intentions and wandered aimlessly into a path with no idea how to complete it, and along the way, found a heart. He sounds like all of them: Welcome to the Mighty Nein.

The Mighty Nein

 * Beauregard Lionett
 * Caduceus Clay
 * Caleb Widogast
 * Fjord
 * Frumpkin
 * Jester Lavorre
 * Nott the Brave/Veth Brenatto
 * Yasha Nydoorin

New

 * Lord Athesius Uludan
 * Lord Desran Thane
 * Carlos Ramedi
 * Lord Robert Sharpe
 * Marquis Zaif
 * Captain Dremmy

Returning

 * Wensforth
 * Wharfmaster Ignus
 * Marius LePual
 * Orly Skiffback
 * Martinet Ludinus Da'leth
 * Essek Thelyss
 * Luc Brenatto
 * Bluud
 * Marion Lavorre
 * Yeza Brenatto
 * Yussa Errenis

Quotations
Essek: Well, I am surprised myself. Maybe you should try friends sometime. Nott: No. But I’m going to do it anyway. I’m not sure what will happen afterwards, but no matter what, you guys will help me get through it. And if for some reason I don’t come back, or come back different, or leave, or something, you know how much you all mean to me. Jester, I hope we have more adventures together. Jester: Me too. I give Nott a kiss on the nose. Nott: Caduceus, thank you for being honest and showing us that you can be scared too, and that’s okay. Yasha, I’m like 60% sure you’re not evil now. Yasha: That should be a lower percentage. Would you like a sip of your wine? Nott: No, thanks. Fjord, I’m sorry that I always call you weak. But I only do that because I know you’re strong enough to take it. Beau, thank you for taking care of Mr Caleb. And Caleb, you know, I love you, and you’re the second love of my life. Thank you for being with me. Caleb: I... love you too, Veth the Brave. Essek: "There is no path to redemption for me. If what has been done comes to light, if what you are seemingly looking to correct is known, then I am a dead man." Caleb: I lean in and kiss him right here and say, "Maybe you and I are both damned, but we can choose to do something, and leave it better than it was before.”
 * Ludinus: I’m surprised to see such affection from such a previously cold individual.
 * Caleb: I hold out my hand to Nott. Are you sure you are ready?
 * Essek: I have a lot I want to accomplish, and only one person who understood and believed in that idea, and that's me. I have done terrible things in my life, as I know many of you have as well. Things you regret. Things you think you're doing for the right reasons. I cannot say I regret what I've done. I just regret how things have changed since I made that decision. You weren't part of the plan.
 * Caduceus: If he says it out loud, then he's going to have to hear what it is and he's not going to like who he is when he hears it.
 * Caleb: I drop down to my knees in front of him and turn his face to mine. "You listen to me. I know what you are talking about. I know. And the difference between you and I is thinner than a razor. I know what it means to have other people complicate your desires and wishes. And I was like you. Was. I know what a fool I have been for years," and I'm looking at him as if I am looking in a mirror. "You didn't account for us. Good. That is life. Shit hits you sideways in life and no one is prepared. No one is ready. These people changed me. These people can change you. You were not born with venom in your veins. You learned it. You learned it. You have a rare opportunity here, Thelyss. One chance to save yourself, and we are offering it. And I am" -- I place a hand on his shoulder -- "pleading with you to find your better self. He is still there."
 * Veth: You are a broken person who had ill intentions and wandered aimlessly into a path that you had no intention or no idea how to complete. And yet somehow along the way, you found a heart. You sound like all of us. Welcome to the Mighty Nein.

Trivia

 * Although the live show and stream were scheduled to begin one hour earlier than normal at 18:00 PST, problems at the venue delayed the start time until approximately 19:35 PST.